What You Said
A few weeks ago I asked you to describe Lean in three words, and I promised to come back with what showed up, what didn’t, and the mistakes I see most often. Thank you to everyone who played. The answers tell me a lot about how Lean gets taught, and about what gets lost along the way.
What Showed Up Less Often
Some words barely appeared, mostly because they come from the Lean vocabulary that rarely makes it out of the training room. [Insert the words John added in his perspective section.]
Common Mistakes Hiding in the Popular Answers
None of the top answers are wrong. Several of them carry a common misunderstanding that sends improvement work in the wrong direction.
The first is efficiency. You can make an operation very efficient at work that shouldn’t exist at all. We made a more efficient typewriter, and people stopped using typewriters anyway. Think about the products and whole companies that became obsolete because they chased efficiency harder than they chased innovation for the customer. Lean starts by asking whether the work should be done, and only then asks how to do it more efficiently.
The second is customer focus. Nearly everyone agrees with it, and most organizations define the customer wrong. Lean defines the customer as the end user, what we call the Big C customer, a definition that came out of MIT. In a car company, the Big C customer is the person who drives the car, and the dealer sits in the middle. In pharma, it’s the patient, and the pharmacy and the hospital sit in the middle. All the handoffs between production and that end user are where waste piles up. Jeff Bezos built Amazon by cutting out wholesalers and middle distribution channels to go straight to the user. Michael Dell did the same with Dell Computers, and Gary Garfield did it with Bridgestone. These leaders all understood who the real customer was.
The third is value. Some people say value means quality and price. The Big C customer wants more than that. They want it when they need it, they want it to be cost-effective, and they want the process of getting it to be easy instead of a pain. In pharma, the patient also wants safety, no side effects, and a problem solved instead of covered with a bandage. Value in the eyes of the customer is always more than one thing, and if you’ve only defined one, your improvement work is aimed at part of the target. In some cases, solving one problem may create three other problems.
Try It Again
Now that you’ve seen the mistakes, take another pass. If you described Lean in three words today, would your answer change? Post your new three words in the comments, and tell me which mistake you recognized in your own organization.
If your teams are running improvement events that make the wrong work faster, my two-day executive workshop gets your leadership team to agree on who the Big C customer is and what they value.