The most common reason I hear for an executive resignation is that they took a better position somewhere else. It’s true often enough that most leadership teams accept it and move on. It’s also the first why, and the first why almost never tells you what to fix.
In Lean we use the Five Whys to trace an undesirable effect back to its root cause. You ask why something happened, then ask why about that answer, and keep going. If you want the real reason a leader left, you have to ask why five times.
Start With the Exit Interview
Take a composite example. A CFO, call her Dana, resigns after two years. Her exit interview says she accepted a better opportunity. Write that down word for word, then ask why it was better.
One version of her chain might look like this.
- Why did she leave? The opportunity elsewhere was better than the one she had.
- Why wasn’t the opportunity here enough? The executive team didn’t take her seriously.
- Why didn’t they? She was constantly fighting battles and getting nowhere.
- Why so many battles? Every executive was working a different agenda.
- Why the different agendas? The senior team had never agreed on a direction or on how to get there.
Or maybe the culture was cutthroat and she was working 80 hours a week. Those are the answers the five whys tool tends to surface once you get past the polite version.
Let the Whys Branch
People rarely leave for one reason, and the five whys don’t have to run in a straight line. Dana might say she left for two reasons. She didn’t feel like she fit in anymore, and she got a better offer.
Follow the first branch and you hear that she was met with resistance, overworked, underappreciated, and felt like she was beating her head against the wall. Follow the second branch and you find that a recruiter called at a moment when she was already unhappy. The offer gave her a way out, and the unhappiness is why she took it.
When the whys branch like this, the tool becomes what’s called a reality tree. You map several undesirable effects back to a small number of root causes. In Dana’s case both branches lead to the same place, an executive team that wasn’t united. Fix that, and you protect the next CFO and probably the VP of operations too.
Ask Before They Leave
The exit interview is the last chance to learn why someone is going, and by then the decision is made. You can run the same questions with the executives who are still with you. Ask what’s getting in the way of their work, what they’ve stopped raising because it goes nowhere, and what would make them take a recruiter’s call. Then ask why about each answer. Learn to pull with thoughtful Socratic questions rather than push with authority and the illusion of control.
Use facts and leave opinions out, and be ready to hear something about yourself. If your executives can’t answer those questions honestly with you, that tells you something.
Run It This Week
Pick the last leader who resigned from your organization. Get two or three people who worked closely with them in a room, start with what the exit interview said, and ask why five times. Draw the branches. When they meet, you’ve found something worth changing.
If your reality tree keeps leading back to the leadership table, my two-day executive workshop starts there, getting the senior team aligned on the direction and the how.